Soy may help protect against cardiovascular disease
Emily R. Cena, UC Davis
Francene M. Steinberg, UC Davis
California Agriculture 65(3):118-123. DOI: 10.3733/ca.v065n03p118.
E.R. Cena is Senior Writer, UC Davis Department of Nutrition. F.M. Steinberg is Professor and Department Chair, UC Davis Department of Nutrition.
Diet and lifestyle choices are major factors contributing to the risk of cardiovascular disease, which is responsible for more deaths in the United States than any other cause. One dietary component that has received considerable attention for its potential cardioprotective effects is soybeans, which contain lean vegetable protein, dietary fiber and bioactive compounds known as isoflavones. Recent research investigating the relationship between soy and cardiovascular disease has identified several potential mechanisms for the observed protective effects, including cholesterol-lowering properties, antioxidant activity and gene regulation. This review highlights current understanding of the complex relationship between soy and the risk of cardiovascular disease.
Soybeans and foods made from soy are the major source of isoflavones, which serve as antioxidants, scavenging and neutralizing free radicals that might otherwise cause inflammation and increase the risk of heart disease.
Cardiovascular disease — comprised of heart disease, heart failure and stroke — is the leading cause of death in the United States. The estimated combined costs of health care services, medications and lost productivity attributed to cardiovascular disease were more than $475 billion in 2009 (Lloyd-Jones et al. 2009).
Although this chronic inflammatory disease affects the lives of millions of Americans, the development of cardiovascular disease is somewhat preventable. Since diet is arguably the most modifiable risk factor, scientists have devoted a great deal of research to the relationship between dietary choices and cardiovascular disease. A healthy diet is generally high in fruits, vegetables, whole grains and legumes. These plant foods tend to be rich in bioactive compounds, or “extra-nutritional” constituents, that are associated with reducing the risk of cardiovascular disease.
One dietary component of considerable research interest is soybeans, a legume linked to the decreased risk of cardiovascular disease. Epidemiological studies suggest that Asian populations consuming large amounts of soy have lower rates of cardiovascular disease than Western populations (Zhang et al. 2003). In the mid-1990s, a meta-analysis of 29 clinical trials found that compared to animal protein, soy protein significantly reduced blood levels of several lipids (total cholesterol, LDL cholesterol and triglycerides) (Anderson et al. 1995). This prompted the U.S. Food and Drug Administration to approve the current health claim that 25 grams of soy protein per day, as part of a diet low in saturated fat and cholesterol, may reduce the risk of heart disease.
While an American Heart Association statement issued in 2006 supported the inclusion of soy in the diet, it was not definitive about the protective mechanism of action (Lichtenstein et al. 2006). Research over the past 10 years has reported mixed results due to varying study designs and soy preparations, but the literature overall still supports the conclusion that soy protein with isoflavones can decrease blood levels of LDL cholesterol (Zhan and Ho 2005). Moreover, recent studies suggest that the relationship between soy and cardiovascular disease is more complex than just lowering cholesterol to protect against atherosclerosis.
Soybeans provide high-quality vegetable protein, dietary fiber and bioactive compounds called isoflavones, a class of phytochemicals (or plant compounds) that provide health benefits. Many different phytochemicals have been identified in nature and studied for their health effects. For example, anthocyanins found in red, blue and purple fruits and vegetables (such as berries and grapes) have been associated with reduced inflammation and lower risk of heart disease. Sulforaphane, a phytochemical found in broccoli and other cruciferous vegetables, may reduce the risk of certain types of cancer.
Isoflavones are found almost exclusively in soybeans and foods made from soy. The cardiovascular health benefits associated with isoflavones appear to be due to the fact that in the body they serve as antioxidants, which neutralize the free radicals that cause oxidative damage to cells. A free radical is a molecule containing an unpaired electron, which makes it highly reactive. Within blood vessels, free radicals can oxidize circulating LDL cholesterol, starting a cascade of inflammatory events that ultimately increase the risk of developing heart disease. Antioxidants interfere with this process by neutralizing, or scavenging, the free radicals.
Likewise, soy acts like compounds similar to the hormone estrogen, affecting processes including blood vessel dilation and gene regulation (fig. 1, page 120). Some health concerns have been raised related to soy's estrogenlike properties, particularly with regard to breast cancer risk, but these concerns are beyond the scope of the current article. Soy protein has also been shown to provide health benefits, such as helping to reduce LDL cholesterol levels. In addition, eating intact soy protein and isoflavones may improve vascular function better than either component by itself (Steinberg et al. 2003).
Fig. 1. Overview of the absorption, metabolism, distribution and excretion of soy isoflavone metabolites.
The amount of isoflavones in a person's diet does not directly determine their bioavailability, the amount of isoflavone metabolites that reach the body's tissues and so are available to exert physiological effects. Rather, bioavailability depends on absorption, metabolism, distribution and excretion (fig. 1) (Lampe and Chang 2007). The isoflavones in soy are not biologically active until after they are digested and absorbed in the small intestine. Enzymes in the small intestine remove glycoside, or sugar, residues from the isoflavones, turning them into bioactive forms that can be absorbed.
In humans, the primary forms of bioactive isoflavone are daidzein and genistein, which are similar to the hormone estrogen. Daidzein and genistein are absorbed along the length of the small intestine, where they undergo further metabolism. The resulting variety of isoflavone metabolites, such as glucuronides and sulphates, then leave the liver and enter the systemic circulation. These metabolites travel to various tissues of the body, where they exert their cellular effects.
Some isoflavone metabolites are secreted by the liver into bile, which is then secreted into the small intestine. There, the isoflavone metabolites in the bile once again undergo digestion and absorption. This recycling process is known as enterohepatic (or intestine-liver) circulation. Another type of recycling, known as enteric recycling, occurs in the small intestine, where isoflavones are metabolized into glucuronidated and sulphated forms that are then secreted back into the intestine for further reabsorption and metabolism (Chen et al. 2003).
Bioactive compounds: Any chemical compounds, organic or inorganic, that exert physiological effects on a living organism. Bioactive compounds generally refer to those found in foods or metabolites formed in the body that affect human health, such as soy isoflavones.
Cholesterol (HDL, LDL, total): A type of lipid that is used by the body for cell membrane structure, cell signaling and the synthesis of hormones, bile and vitamin D. Sources include synthesis by the liver and the dietary intake of animal products. Cholesterol is transported through the bloodstream bound to lipoproteine that are classified according to their lipid-to-protein ratio. Low-density lipoproteins (LDL) contain relatively large amounts of fat and cholesterol compared to protein, whereas high-density lipoproteins (HDL) contain more protein and less cholesterol. LDL cholesterol is often referred to as “bad” cholesterol because it can become oxidized by free radicals, resulting in inflammation and atherosclerosis. High levels of HDL cholesterol, sometimes called “good” cholesterol, are associated with lower risk of heart disease and other chronic diseases, possibly because HDL molecules transport cholesterol to the liver for excretion.
Cytokines: Intercellular signaling molecules involved in physiological processes such as inflammation. Cytokines consist of many different small molecules that enable cells to communicate. Some examples include tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-?) and interleukins such as interleukin-6 (IL-6), both of which are involved in the inflammatory process.
Endothelial cells, function: Cells that line blood vessels throughout the body, providing a barrier between the bloodstream and body tissues. They are actively involved in blood clotting, controlling white blood cell migration in and out of the bloodstream during the inflammatory response, and constriction and dilation of blood vessels.
Estrogen: A primary sex hormone that performs a number of important functions related to human health. Although present at higher levels in women, estrogen helps regulate reproductive development and function in men and women. Estrogen reduces the risk of cardiovascular disease by decreasing LDL cholesterol and triglyceride levels, and increasing HDL cholesterol. Estrogen also plays a key role in bone health.
Triglyceride: The predominant form of fat in food and in the body, consisting of a glycerol backbone with three fatty acids bound to it. Most circulating fat and most fat stored in adipose cells is in the form of triglycerides. Elevated triglyceride levels are a marker of increased risk for heart disease, diabetes and other chronic diseases, and high triglycerides are one of the defining components of the metabolic syndrome.
Enterohepatic circulation and enteric recycling of isoflavones are important because they allow body tissues to be exposed to these phytochemicals for longer amounts of time following soy intake. After absorption, metabolism and distribution, isoflavones are ultimately excreted in urine, and most excretion occurs within 24 hours of consuming a soy-containing meal (Setchell et al. 2003). Isoflavones that pass through the small intestine without being bioactivated then pass into the colon, where precursors to the bioactive form of daidzein are instead metabolized by bacteria into another bioactive compound called equol. The equol is then absorbed into the bloodstream and transported to various body tissues, where it appears to exhibit greater antioxidant and estrogenic effects than daidzein (Arora et al. 1998; Mitchell et al. 1998). Although there are other bacterial byproducts of isoflavone metabolism in the colon, equol is the primary one with significant bioactivity in humans.
Not all humans have colonic bacteria capable of producing equol. Equol is produced by an estimated 30% to 40% of white persons (Lampe et al. 1998) and up to 60% of Asians (Morton et al. 2002). Factors associated with equol production are not fully understood but are believed to include genetics, diet and lifestyle, in addition to the composition of gut microflora (Atkinson et al. 2008). It is unclear whether equol producers have increased protection against cardiovascular disease compared to nonproducers, and this remains a topic of great research interest (Atkinson et al. 2005).
Atherosclerosis, which hardens and narrows the arteries, is a primary cause of cardiovascular disease (see box). The development of atherosclerosis is quite complex, involving chronic inflammation, the generation of reactive oxygen species, abnormal endothelial cell function, lipid-laden foam cell formation and clot formation within blood vessels. The observed protective effect of soy and soy isoflavones on atherosclerosis and cardiovascular disease risk appears to be related to a number of different mechanisms.
In cardiovascular disease, the blood vessels become constricted or blocked, forcing the heart to work harder to push blood through the body. One factor that promotes blood vessel dilation (vasodilation) is the production of nitric oxide by endothelial cells in the blood vessel wall. Estrogen can rapidly increase endothelial nitric oxide production (Rimbach et al. 2008), providing anti-atherosclerotic effects. Because isoflavones are so similar to estrogens, they can also rapidly increase endothelial nitric oxide production, enhancing vasodilation and improving blood flow.
Another factor contributing to the development of cardiovascular disease is inflammation in blood vessels. In animal models, estrogen decreases the levels of two small proteins (cytokines TNF-? and IL-6) that increase inflammation, reducing the risk of cardiovascular disease (Ito et al. 2001). It is unclear whether isoflavones similarly inhibit the production of proinflammatory cytokines in humans (Beavers et al. 2009), but this remains a current area of research interest.
Soy can reduce LDL cholesterol circulating in the blood, thereby decreasing the formation of plaque in blood vessel walls.
In addition to the widely recognized cholesterol-lowering effects of soy protein, soy isoflavones also help lower both total and LDL cholesterol levels, while increasing cardioprotective HDL cholesterol (Taku et al. 2007; Zhan and Ho 2005). In fact, the combination of soy protein and isoflavones appears to exhibit the strongest hypocholesterolemic effects compared to isolated soy protein or soy isoflavones alone (Mortensen et al. 2009). Whole soy can promote a 3% to 5% reduction in blood cholesterol (Lichtenstein et al. 2006; Zhan and Ho 2005). Although soy's effects are not as large as the 20% or greater reductions observed with statin drug therapy (Rosenson 2006), even a 3% to 5% reduction can have clinical significance. Reduced circulating LDL cholesterol means less is available to become oxidized and retained in lipid plaques in the blood vessel wall. Less oxidized LDL cholesterol results in a lower risk of atherosclerosis and therefore cardiovascular disease.
Another way to reduce LDL cholesterol oxidation, aside from decreasing the amount that is circulating, is to prevent or slow oxidation through the action of antioxidants. Soy isoflavones and their metabolites, particularly genistein and equol, have antioxidant properties.
In 2006, cardiovascular disease was responsible for 26% of all deaths in the United States (Heron et al. 2009). In California alone, it claimed the lives of more than 73,000 people in 2004 — more than cancer, diabetes, chronic liver disease, homicide, suicide and HIV/AIDS combined (Reynen et al. 2007). The costs associated with the treatment of cardiovascular disease are staggering, particularly at a time when health care costs in the United States have never been higher.
Several risk factors for cardiovascular disease are at least partially modifiable by lifestyle choices, including obesity, high blood pressure, diabetes, chronic inflammation, dyslipidemia (abnormally high blood cholesterol and/or triglycerides), smoking, physical inactivity and dietary choices.
Two studies in humans demonstrated that daily consumption of soy protein with isoflavones reduced levels of LDL oxidation (Tikkanen et al. 1998; Wiseman et al. 2000). In vitro studies have revealed potential mechanisms for the antioxidant activity of isoflavones, including: (1) their ability to scavenge free radicals and chelate metals (or bind to metals, making them less chemically reactive); (2) their role in inhibiting the production of hydrogen peroxide, a naturally occurring cellular byproduct that oxidizes compounds and damages blood vessel walls, stressing the body by inflammation; and (3) their capacity to stimulate the production of antioxidant enzymes such as superoxide dismutase (Mortensen et al. 2009).
Soy isoflavones increase the levels of cardioprotective HDL (“good”) cholesterol and decrease levels of LDL (“bad”) cholesterol, lowering the risk of heart disease.
Reactive oxygen species are molecules, ions or free radicals that contain oxygen and are highly reactive because of unpaired electrons. Cellular processes produce them naturally, but large amounts cause oxidative damage. A key partner in cellular defenses against oxidative damage is the transcription factor Nrf2, which promotes the transcription of genes for various antioxidant and detoxifying enzymes. The activation of antioxidant genes via the Nrf2 pathway is a potential role for isoflavones (Mann et al. 2009).
Soy isoflavones help promote vasodilation by stimulating nitric oxide production in the endothelial cells lining blood vessels. Interestingly, macrophages (a type of white blood cell) also produce nitric oxide during the inflammatory response, in an effort to destroy foreign particles such as bacteria. In cases of chronic inflammation, however, increased nitric oxide production by macrophages causes oxidative stress that contributes to the formation of atherosclerotic plaques, thereby increasing the risk of cardiovascular disease. Soy isoflavones are able to inhibit inducible nitric oxide production in macrophages, reducing excessive oxidative stress (Rimbach et al. 2008).
Soy isoflavones can promote vasodilation by stimulating the production of nitric oxide. A recent study showed that genistein, one of the estrogenlike forms of isoflavones, modified the expression of genes that encode for a number of proteins related to vasodilation and blood pressure (Ambra et al. 2006). While in vitro and animal studies seem to support the vasodilatory effects of isoflavones, a review of human intervention studies found conflicting results, with some studies reporting improved vasodilation and others reporting no change (Mortensen et al. 2009). In addition, isoflavones appear to promote vasodilation in ways that do not involve estrogenic effects. More research is necessary to better elucidate the relationship between isoflavones and vasodilation in humans.
One of the greatest threats of cardiovascular disease is the formation of clots within blood vessels. If a blood clot forms and breaks loose, it can travel to a coronary artery (which supplies the heart with blood), block the artery and cause a lifethreatening heart attack. Similarly, if a clot obstructs the blood supply to the brain, it can cause a stroke. A key step in the formation of blood clots is platelet aggregation. Although the mechanism is not yet fully understood, in vitro and animal studies have demonstrated that soy isoflavones inhibit platelet aggregation, reducing the risk of blood clots (Gottstein et al. 2003; Peluso et al. 2000). It remains to be demonstrated whether this effect occurs in humans with typical levels of circulating isoflavones.
High blood pressure is one of the factors of metabolic syndrome, which results in higher risks of cardiovascular disease and type 2 diabetes. The consumption of soy lowered blood pressure in a study of postmenopausal women.
A growing body of evidence supports the gene regulatory effects of soy isoflavones, both through their estrogenic and antioxidant properties. Genistein has been shown to inhibit the DNA binding of a transcription factor called NF-?B, resulting in the reduced transcription of several vascular cell adhesion molecules that are crucial to the development of atherosclerotic plaques. Inhibition of NF-?B or other such transcription factors could slow the progression of atherosclerosis (Nagarajan 2010). In addition, in cultures of the endothelial cells that line blood vessels, physiologically relevant levels of genistein upregulated the transcription factor peroxisome proliferator–activated receptor gamma (PPAR-gamma), which resulted in reduced adhesion of monocytes (a type of white blood cell) to vessel walls (Chacko et al. 2007).
Abdominal obesity is another factor of metabolic syndrome. Eating soy may help people improve glycemie control.
Similarly, both genistein and daidzein reduce the transcription of a protein called MCP-1 that attracts monocytes (Mortensen et al. 2009). MCP-1 is involved in atherogenesis because it is known to recruit monocytes and other immune system cells into the arterial wall, contributing to plaque formation. By reducing the secretion of MCP-1 and so inhibiting monocyte infiltration into the blood vessel wall, soy isoflavones may help prevent the formation of plaque.
As researchers continue to learn more about the nutrigenomics of soy, or the effects of soy on gene expression, it is likely they will find wide variation in the way individuals digest, absorb, metabolize, distribute and eliminate isoflavones and their metabolites. As with equol producers versus nonproducers, genetic and environmental factors appear to mediate the relationship between soy intake and cardiovascular disease risk. These individual variations may help explain why human intervention studies have given mixed results.
Metabolic syndrome is a constellation of risk factors including abdominal obesity, high blood pressure, insulin resistance and alterations in blood lipids that results in increased risk of cardiovascular disease and type 2 diabetes. The prevalence of metabolic syndrome is rising at an alarming rate in the United States (Ford et al. 2004). Dietary and lifestyle modifications are central to managing the syndrome.
The role of soy in ameliorating metabolic syndrome and its associated risk factors is an emerging area of nutrition research. Rodent models have demonstrated that soy diets can reduce adiposity and circulating cholesterol levels and improve insulin sensitivity (Davis et al. 2007; Ronis et al. 2009). Human studies have also supported the protective effects of soy against risk factors associated with metabolic syndrome. Postmenopausal women with the syndrome who consumed soy nuts showed improvements in glycemic control and blood lipids as well as a marker of inflammation (Azadbakht et al. 2007). In contrast, adults with type 2 diabetes who consumed soy protein had beneficial changes in blood lipid profiles but not glycemic control (Pipe et al. 2009). Hypertensive, postmenopausal women who consumed soy nuts had improvements in blood pressure that were associated with markers of endothelial function, suggesting a decrease in vascular inflammation (Welty et al. 2007).
To date, little is known about potential fetal or prepubertal exposure to soy and its influence on cardiovascular risk later in life, but it is possible that these unexplored questions might help explain some of the beneficial effects of soy observed in Asian populations (Bonacasa et al. 2011).
Research strategies have previously focused on consumption of soy protein and isoflavones in relatively healthy individuals, examining effects on vascular outcomes and safety (Heneman et al. 2007; Steinberg et al. 2003; Steinberg et al. 2011). Currently, a research project funded by the Center for Health and Nutrition Research is under way at UC Davis to investigate the effects of consuming whole soy foods on biomarkers of cardiovascular risk in individuals with metabolic syndrome; it may be completed in 2012.
The cardioprotective effects of soy appear to be mediated by several mechanisms related to the inflammatory processes of atherosclerosis, involving both genomic and nongenomic activities. Soy isoflavones have a broad variety of biological actions. The beneficial effects of soy are modest compared to pharmacological treatment, such as statin drugs. However, the cumulative effects over a lifetime are likely to be significant. Soy and its bioactive isoflavone components are an important part of a diet rich in foods for health promotion.
The beneficial effects of soy have been observed in Asian populations, which have lower heart disease rates than Western populations.
Robert M. Hackman, Research Nutritionist in the UC Davis Department of Nutrition, served as Guest Associate Editor for this article. This work was supported in part by the UC Davis Center for Health and Nutrition Research, established with funding from the State of California Vitamin Price Fixing Consumer Settlement Fund.